The Wacky Sister Wives Fan Theory Coming to the Major Stage After Kody and Janelle’s Son Garrison Suicide

Viewers watching the current season of TLC’s Sister Wives are convinced that some scenes were refilmed after the suicide of Kody and Janelle Brown’s son Garrison, who sadly died on March 5, 2024.

The fourth episode of season 19, titled How The Mighty Have Fallen, includes the polygamist family’s plans for Thanksgiving in 2022 – meaning it was filmed almost two years ago in November, but fans think that a particular scene involving Kody, 55, and his wife Robyn, 46, may have been filmed much more recently.

About halfway through episode four, it’s confirmed that the couple “had a heated exchange shortly before the cameras arrived” as Robyn is “extremely upset” that Kody isn’t reaching out more to some of his friends. children he shares with his ex-wife Janelle. 55.

Speaking to the camera, Kody didn’t name which kids he was talking about, just called them “those people,” while Robyn confessed to him as they stood outside in the snow: “I’m so worried about these children.’

Sisters Wives viewers are convinced the scenes involving Kody and Robyn Brown in season 19 were filmed recently

Garrison Brown, pictured here with his mom Janelle, separated from his father Kody and committed suicide in March 2024

Viewers believe Robyn and Kody’s heated exchange was refilmed after Garrison’s suicide

Kody and Janelle welcomed a total of six children during their 29-year “spiritual union” that ended in 2022, and she recently claimed that her ex-husband “didn’t have much contact with any of them.” their children” since the COVID-19 pandemic. .

Referring to episode four, which aired on October 6, a viewer took to Reddit and claimed that Kody and Robyn’s “fight” took place in March 2024, and they had several reasons to think so, including including the weather.

“Snow on the ground doesn’t really make sense for November 2022, given that not all Thanksgiving images had snow on the ground,” they wrote.

“Robyn’s eyebrows look more like her 2024 era than her 2022 era. If this is true, I am incredibly angry at the production team for facilitating this fake conversation,” the Reddit user added .

Others were quick to comment on the thread, with one person claiming: “I’m part of the team, there was an original, still staged – where he talked about MAD S* *T about Gabe and Garrison and production allowed them to reshoot and take the majority of the film.” shit, that doesn’t speak to boys.

Another person commented: “I agree with you, but they are so cheap I’m not even sure they have been completely redone.” In the scene where he says he tried to contact Gabe, there’s a quick cut so you don’t actually see his face when he says Gabe’s name.

“It cuts to her back/Robyn’s face before cutting right back to Kody’s face. I think he said “Gabriel and Garrison” and they just came back and dubbed the audio. Classic reality TV Franken quote,” they suggested.

Someone else pointed out, “The language used in this fight with Robyn encouraging Kody to ‘call him’ (he shouldn’t be named) is extremely suspicious,” before claiming it was about Garrison.

Eagle-eyed viewers spotted several clues that the scene was filmed more recently, including the weather and Kody’s coat.

Garrison, pictured with his brother Gabe (left), who is also separated from Kody

“There is no doubt that they are trying to rewrite their absent role regarding Garrison’s depression,” they charged.

Another viewer came in and said: “I wondered when I watched what year and month it was actually filmed. I suspect a lot of editing and re-filming went into this season’s hot mess. I try to tell by their hair and their weight. I don’t think this movie was Thanksgiving.

“Viewer detectives said the brand of coat Kody is wearing isn’t available until September 2023. They also checked weather maps and said there was snow in March in Flagstaff, so they think that the argument scene was filmed in March 2024,” they added. .

However, other Sister Wives fans disagreed and were quick to refute these claims, as one person wrote on Reddit: “I mean, there was snow on the ground in December 2022 as well. Analysis of Kody’s jacket could indicate that it will be filmed later in 2023, however.

“I find it hard to believe that Kody would have said some of the things he did after JUST losing a child,” they added.

Another commented: “Finally! A bit of critical thinking here. I can’t even imagine her willingly replaying something after her child’s death.

A third person said: “I think this is a ridiculous conspiracy theory because the supposed ‘reshoot’ doesn’t even accomplish the goal of making Kody look like a caring father.” And someone else responded and wrote, “I agree that production just went through and deleted G’s name and any footage of him they had in this current season.”

“I think they could have had some that wouldn’t have shown G in the best light and, out of respect for Janelle, the production wanted to protect her memory.”

In the latest episode, which aired October 13, Gabe detailed the “strange” conversation he had with Kody via text message.

During the most recent episode of Season 19, which aired on October 13, Kody’s ninth child, Gabriel “Gabe” Brown, detailed the “weird” conversation they recently had while he was taking his breakfast with her mother, Janelle.

“He said to me, ‘Hey, I miss you.’ And then he said he kept phrasing it like I owed him an apology,” the sensitive 23-year-old recalls.

“And finally I was like, ‘Hey, unless you’re actually ready to have a relationship and work things out, then we’re not going to talk anymore.’ ” “

A few days later, Gabe received a text from his father that said, “I’ve been thinking about what you said. I forgive you, please forgive me.’ I was like, forgive me for what?’

“I told Dad that if he doesn’t change and he can’t take responsibility, I’ll never see him again and I’m totally okay with that,” Gabe noted.